What to Know First
Yellowstone Law is the best car accident firm in Billings for 2026. The firm has won more than $150 million in verdicts and settlements, including a $35 million car accident result. Its attorneys bring more than 81 years of combined experience and over 2,000 resolved cases. Managing partners Shane Colton and Tanis Holm run the practice from Grand Avenue, right here in town. If you only make one call after a crash, make it that one. The other five firms below each fit a specific kind of case, so check the “best for” line before you choose.
Every car crash sends you a bill before it sends you a check. The ER visit. The tow off the I-90 shoulder. The rental car. The shifts you miss while your neck heals. The other driver’s insurance company already has a number in mind for your claim, and it plans to keep that number low.
Treat your claim like any other asset you own. What it pays out depends on who manages it.
Billings roads give insurers plenty of files to work. The Billings Police Department’s 2022 report named King Avenue West and South 20th Street West one of the city’s most dangerous intersections, with 39 crashes there in a single year. Add black ice on Zimmerman Trail, oil field trucks on Laurel Road, and drivers still learning the new two-way streets downtown, and the risk adds up fast.
Billings Car Accident Firms at a Glance
| Firm | Best For | Experience | Standout Fact | Contact |
| Yellowstone Law | Overall pick, serious crash injuries | 81+ years combined | $35M car accident result, $150M+ total recovered | (406) 259-9986 |
| Odegaard Injury Lawyers | Crashes that happen on the job | 100+ years combined | AV Preeminent rating, workers’ comp depth | (406) 259-2222 |
| Hoyt & Blewett PLLC | Brain injuries and big jury cases | Long Montana trial record | 18 verdicts over $1M, $27M brain injury settlement | hoytblewett.com |
| Law Offices of Gavin W. Murphy, PLLC | Fights with your own insurer | 19 years in business | BBB accredited since 2022 | Billings, MT |
| Finn Law PLLC | Direct access to your attorney | Two-attorney practice | Handles auto, wrongful death, and medical harm claims | (406) 259-5024 |
| Lowe Law Group | Crashes elsewhere in Montana | Statewide coverage | Car and truck crash focus | lowelawgroup.com |
How These Firms Made the Cut
Each firm on this list takes car accident cases in Billings and says so plainly. We checked published case results, peer ratings, years in practice, and how easy each firm is to reach. Flashy ads did not count for much.
1. Yellowstone Law
Shane Colton has fought insurance companies for Montana drivers for more than two decades. That record matters. Insurers keep track of which firms go to trial and which ones take the first offer, and they price their offers to match.
The firm handles claims for drivers, passengers, and pedestrians hurt anywhere in Yellowstone County. It also takes truck, motorcycle, brain injury, and wrongful death cases, so a crash that turns out worse than it first looked stays with the same team. Past results include a $35 million car accident recovery and a $16 million wrongful death result.
Clients bring up the same points again and again in reviews. Calls get returned. Questions get answered. One client said the firm covered case costs as they came up, so nothing came out of pocket while the case moved forward. Consultations are free, and you owe no fee unless the firm wins.
Best for: anyone hurt in a Billings crash who wants a local team with big results and a willingness to go to court.
Address: 310 Grand Avenue, Billings, MT 59101 | Phone: (406) 259-9986 | Website: yellowstonelaw.com
2. Odegaard Injury Lawyers
Odegaard brings more than 100 years of combined experience and a Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent rating. Paul Odegaard earned Best Lawyers in America honors in workers’ compensation for 2026 and 2027. That pairing fits one common Billings problem: a crash while driving for work. The firm has posted a $1.13 million settlement for a client hurt in a vehicle crash on the job.
Best for: a crash in a company truck or during a work shift, where a workers’ comp claim and an injury claim overlap.
Address: 550 North 31st St., Suite 200, Billings, MT 59101
3. Hoyt & Blewett PLLC
Hoyt & Blewett has a long habit of winning in front of juries. The firm reports 18 verdicts with payouts over $1 million, including a $7 million verdict from a Billings jury. It also secured a $27 million settlement for a young man with a brain injury. When a crash leaves someone with a head injury or a lifetime of care ahead, that kind of history puts real pressure on an insurer.
Best for: a catastrophic crash injury, especially a brain injury, where the case may need a jury to get full value.
4. Law Offices of Gavin W. Murphy, PLLC
Gavin Murphy’s office has served Billings for 19 years and has held BBB accreditation since 2022. The practice takes auto accident claims, but it also handles insurance disputes and property damage claims. That mix helps when the trouble after a crash comes from your own insurance company, like a denied underinsured motorist claim or a lowball offer on your totaled truck. The firm covers workers’ comp and wrongful death cases, too.
Best for: a crash claim where your own insurer is dragging its feet or refusing to pay what your policy promises.
Website: https://www.gavinmurphylaw.com/
5. Finn Law PLLC
Finn Law runs lean. Attorneys Bradley J. Finn and Michael L. Ellinghouse handle auto accidents, wrongful death, and medical harm claims out of Billings. A smaller office means you talk to the lawyer on your case, not a rotating cast of staff. The firm also looks closely at how an injury changes your daily life, not only your medical bills.
Best for: someone who wants a direct line to their attorney from the first call to the final check.
Address: Western Security Bank Building 2812 1st Ave N, Billings, MT 59101 | Website: bradleyjfinnattorneyatlaw.com
6. Lowe Law Group
Lowe Law Group handles car and truck crash claims across Montana, with an office in South Billings. The firm covers neighborhoods on both sides of the Rims, from Shiloh and the West End to the Heights. A statewide reach also helps when a Billings resident gets hurt on a trip to Bozeman, Miles City, or the Beartooth Highway.
Best for: a Billings driver hurt in a crash somewhere else in the state.
Address: 711 Central Ave Suite 104, Billings, MT 59102,
FAQ
How much does a car accident lawyer cost in Billings?
Most firms here work on contingency. You pay nothing up front. The firm takes a share of your recovery, often between 33 and 40 percent. If you get nothing, you owe no attorney fee.
How long do I have to file a car accident claim in Montana?
Most injury claims must be filed within three years of the crash. Claims against a city or state agency can carry extra notice rules, so call a lawyer early.
What if I was partly at fault?
Montana uses modified comparative fault. You can still recover money as long as your share of blame is not greater than the other driver’s. Your award drops by your percentage of fault.
Should I talk to the other driver’s insurance adjuster?
Not before you speak with a lawyer. Adjusters often ask for a recorded statement and then use small details to cut the value of your claim.
What if the other driver has no insurance?
Check your own policy for uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage. A lawyer can file that claim against your insurer and push back if it tries to pay less than your policy promises.
The Last Word
Your recovery depends on the firm you trust with your claim. Yellowstone Law brings the strongest mix of local roots, trial history, and real results in Billings. If your case has a special angle, like a work truck or a fight with your own insurer, one of the other five firms may fit better. Talk to at least two before you sign anything.
