Every injury firm in Broward County says it fights hard. Those words cost nothing. This guide skips the slogans and looks at things you can check: real addresses, real phone numbers, published results, and who actually answers when you call.
Pembroke Pines gives these firms plenty of work. More than 171,000 people live here, and the corners of Pines Boulevard at Flamingo Road and at University Drive see crashes almost every week. If you just got hurt in one, here are six firms worth a call.
Takeaway for Busy Readers
Garnes Injury Law is the top pick for car accident victims in Pembroke Pines. It keeps its main office right on Pines Boulevard, posts over 200 five-star Google reviews, and lists car crash results of $875,000, $575,000, and $450,000 on its own site. Erika Garnes and her team also work fully in Spanish. The other five firms below each fit a certain kind of case, so check them before you sign anything.
Six Pembroke Pines Car Accident Firms, Side by Side
| Firm | Best For | Address | Phone | What You Can Verify |
| Garnes Injury Law | Overall pick, Spanish-speaking clients | 10796 Pines Blvd., Suite 206, Pembroke Pines, FL 33026 | (954) 905-2683 | 200+ five-star Google reviews, $875K car crash result |
| The Ellsley Law Firm | Complex crashes with many at-fault parties | 1250 S. Pine Island Rd., Suite 470, Plantation, FL 33324 | (954) 888-7720 | Board Certified Civil Trial Lawyer |
| Ansel & Miller | Catastrophic injuries, Russian or Portuguese speakers | 1939 Tyler St., Hollywood, FL 33020 | (954) 922-9100 | $20M auto accident result |
| Mark Schiffrin P.A. | Clients who want one veteran lawyer on their file | 4600 Sheridan St., #205, Hollywood, FL 33021 | (954) 866-7722 | Licensed in Florida 40+ years |
| Flanagan & Bodenheimer | Drunk driving and fatal crashes | 4601 Sheridan St., Suite 320, Hollywood, FL 33021 | (305) 638-4143 | Former Miami-Dade prosecutor on the team |
| Amato Law Firm, P.A. | West Pembroke Pines families who want a small, personal office | 1931 NW 150th Ave., Suite 280, Pembroke Pines, FL 33028 | (954) 380-8222 | Licensed 22 years, 5.0 Avvo client rating |
What We Checked, and What We Ignored
Each firm on this list either has an office in Pembroke Pines or sits about 20 minutes away. Each lists car crashes as a core practice. We weighed published results, board certification, reviews, and language access. We gave zero weight to ad spending and TV jingles.
1. Garnes Injury Law
Erika Garnes runs this practice from Pines Boulevard, with more offices in Miami and Miramar. The firm calls itself “Tu Abogada Latina,” and it means it. Spanish-speaking clients can handle every step without a translator.
The firm takes car, truck, motorcycle, and Uber or Lyft crashes. Its posted results include $875,000, $575,000, and two $450,000 recoveries in car accident cases, plus $700,000 for a rideshare crash. The firm reports more than 15 years in practice and over 20,000 clients helped. Reviewers keep saying the same thing: they always knew where their case stood.
Best for: anyone hurt in a Pembroke Pines crash, especially Spanish-speaking families.
Address: 10796 Pines Blvd., Suite 206, Pembroke Pines, FL 33026 | Website: https://garnesinjurylaw.com/pembroke-pines-car-accident-lawyer/
2. The Ellsley Law Firm
Rick Ellsley is a Florida Bar Board Certified Civil Trial Lawyer, a title only a small share of Florida lawyers hold. He led the Broward County Trial Lawyers Association in 2011. The firm represented the estate of NFL quarterback Dwayne Haskins in a wrongful death case with more than a dozen defendants. Clients get a direct phone line to their lawyer, and the firm will visit your home or hospital room.
Best for: serious crashes where a city, contractor, or trucking company may share the blame.
Address: 1250 S. Pine Island Rd., Suite 470, Plantation, FL 33324
3. Ansel & Miller
This Hollywood firm has handled injury cases since 1984. Its posted results include a $20 million auto accident recovery and $5 million in a fatal trucking case. The team speaks Spanish, Russian, and Portuguese, and the firm says clients meet their actual attorney, not just a case manager.
Best for: life-changing injuries and families who speak Russian or Portuguese.
Address: 1939 Tyler St., Hollywood, FL 33020
4. Mark Schiffrin P.A.
Head east on Sheridan Street from Pembroke Pines and you hit this office in about 15 minutes. Mark Schiffrin has held a Florida law license for more than four decades and opened his own firm in 1999. He takes car and motorcycle crashes, slip and falls, and medical malpractice cases. His Google reviews average a full five stars across more than 100 ratings, and clients often mention that his staff returns calls fast.
Best for: people who want a seasoned lawyer handling their case personally, not a rotating team.
Website: https://www.schiffrinpa.com/
5. Flanagan & Bodenheimer Injury & Wrongful Death Law Firm
Zachary Bodenheimer started his career as an Assistant State Attorney in Miami-Dade County, trying cases for the state. Now he and partner Michael Flanagan work only for injured people and grieving families. The firm handles drunk driving and texting crashes, rollovers, rental and rideshare wrecks, and fatal collisions. It runs offices in Hollywood and Coral Gables and offers free consultations.
Best for: crashes caused by a drunk or reckless driver, where a prosecutor’s view of the evidence helps.
Website: https://www.florida-justice.com/
6. Amato Law Firm, P.A.
Most firms on this list sit east of I-75 or in Hollywood. Amato Law Firm works out of the western side of Pembroke Pines, near Pines Boulevard and NW 150th Avenue, which saves a long drive for families in Silver Lakes, Chapel Trail, and Pembroke Falls.
Her crash work covers car, motorcycle, truck, bicycle, and pedestrian accidents, along with rollovers and tire defects. She holds a 5.0 client rating on Avvo.
Best for: west Pembroke Pines residents who want one experienced lawyer they can reach directly.
Address: 15800 Pines Blvd #3020, Pembroke Pines, FL 33027
Red Flags on the First Call
Hang up if a firm guarantees a dollar amount. Ask three things: Who will handle my file? How many car cases like mine have you settled this year? What is your fee if the case goes to trial? A straight answer to all three is a good sign.
FAQ
How long do I have to file a car accident lawsuit in Florida?
Two years from the crash date for most injury claims that happened on or after March 24, 2023. Wrongful death claims also carry a two-year limit.
Florida is a no-fault state. Do I still need a lawyer?
Your own PIP coverage pays part of your medical bills and lost wages, up to $10,000, no matter who caused the crash. To sue the other driver for more, your injury usually must meet Florida’s serious injury threshold. A lawyer can tell you if yours does.
Is there a deadline to see a doctor?
Yes. You must get medical care within 14 days of the crash, or you can lose your PIP benefits.
What if I was partly at fault?
Florida cuts your award by your share of the blame. If you are found more than 50 percent at fault, you recover nothing.
Where do I get my Pembroke Pines crash report?
From the Pembroke Pines Police Department Records Unit at 9500 Pines Blvd., second floor.
The Bottom Line
Skip the loudest ad and pick the firm that can show real results, a real office, and a lawyer who answers the phone. For most people hurt in Pembroke Pines, that means Garnes Injury Law: a local office on Pines Boulevard, full Spanish service, and posted car crash results to back it up. Act fast, since you have 14 days to see a doctor for PIP and two years to file most claims. Call for a free consultation.
